Mixing my business with your pleasure

 
Sarah's signed VIP pass
Image by teepoole via Flickr

I have a dilemma. As with many other twitterers and bloggers out there who write about the subject matter they also work with, I sometimes have some potential conflicts of interest. To be more precise, I face some situations that some might pick up on as conflicts in a traditional journalistic sense.

I agree that someone who promotes themselves as a journalist and wants to be seen as an objective reporter of facts and news must be very careful about what products or brands they become associated with. However, I don’t think all bloggers really are journalists. We aim to share news and facts, as we see them, but mainly we try to entertaining you, and have fun as we do it. If you like it, you can follow us, and if you don’t, you can easily stop. We bloggers soon get the message.

So, to the dilemma.

I often come across information about, or even help to organise, wine events, tastings, special offers and more. Some of these, of course, relate to the wines I represent in the UK (which I have chosen not to mention on this blog, but write about elsewhere) or at least to the retailers and restaurants that I meet with regularly.

Should I let you know about these offers through this site, or should I be very selective and avoid the potential of being seen to abuse any trust you have in me as a commentator on wine?

I’m not talking about spamming my readers with hundreds of offers and deals, but if I hear of something I consider interesting, or get the opportunity to suggest something I think readers might enjoy, should I mention it here and do this as openly as possible even if it involves my wines, or business partners’? The alternative is, as I have often done, to participate myself and report on it from the event, but it does mean others can’t get involved.

In fact, turning it around, should I actually be encouraging MORE people to create wine offers for you through Social Media? Of course, I’m not just talking about discounts, but about events that encourage the exploration of wine and support wine culture.

I’m hoping that as many of my readers are also bloggers, or wine trade professionals, you’ll understand the situation and have some advice to offer.

As more and more of the restaurants, wine retailers and wine producers that I talk to want to know more about the possibilities of Social Media, there will be more and more opportunities for this to arise, and I’d like to get a sense of whether I’m getting the balance right, or you feel I may be promoting other businesses too much.

If you want to keep it even more brief you could respond “Yes” or “No”:

  • Yes – let me know of interesting wine related offers (but don’t spam me, just the best bits)
  • No – concentrate on wine writing (and do more of it) and let other sites promote the offers

… but a bit more explanation might help :)

Yours, in some trepidation for what I might be starting, your friendly neighbourhood @thirstforwine

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
  • http://www.ultimatewines.co.uk Paula Sindberg

    Hi Robert -
    I think you can post/write out events, even if you have an interest, but should probably make a disclaimer of your interest. That way people will know of “potential” bias and can make their own decisions. But interesting stuff is interesting stuff. Pass it on. That’s what social media is all about.
    Cheers,
    Paula @UltimateWines

    • http://thirstforwine.co.uk thirstforwine

      thanks. An unfortunate side-effect is that proper disclaimers/explanations can often be longer than the message itself, but I agree that openness works best in the long run. Will do my best ;)

  • http://www.thetastingsessions.com Angella Newell

    As a blogger, you are reporting on your own opinions and experiences. The community who know you and read what you have to say are interested in those opinions.

    It is those experiences and personal relationships which mean you are able to highlight these wines for others to try. Others can make their own decisions about whether to try it or like it.

    I say, be open about the connections. People love to hear story behind a wine, and your personal connection adds to the overall experience.

    • http://thirstforwine.co.uk thirstforwine

      thanks Angella – I do like to focus on the events that have a good reason, rather than gimmicks, so will try my best

  • http://www.americanwinery.com shiz37

    I love that you are bringing up this conversation. It is a dilemma that many are facing – and as someone involved in the whole social media scene, I know that I don’t mind hearing about amazing events/offers/deals as long as whoever is bringing it to my attention lets me know first that they may have a little extra interest in said event/offer/deal. I guess the major rule of thumb in the whole social media world is “Transparency.” We like to hear what you’re up to. That’s why we follow you. If it is something we can be involved in, all the better.

    • http://thirstforwine.co.uk thirstforwine

      well said, and thanks for your support

  • http://carolineld.blogspot.com Caroline

    A definite yes! Since your blog is open about your involvement in the wine trade, an informal mention of any connection to the event should surely be enough of a disclaimer, and even adds interest.

    • http://thirstforwine.co.uk thirstforwine

      an interesting disclaimer might be a hard task to manage, but I get your point. I think that I happen to work with some progressive companies, and if they can be bothered to invest in an event or offer, then it is probably worth giving them the chance to put the offer to you. Thanks for the comment :)

  • Laura

    Yes! the great thing about wine is that it does mix business and pleasure.

    @idiomcollection

  • steveraye

    I’m an agency guy and do social media marketing for a living, so I have a vested interest in brand promotion. That said,I think of wine blogging as B2B journalism…it’s all about being commercial. By definition anyone reading a blog is interested (usually passionately) in the subject, hungry for specific, not superficial information. So promotion in my mind is appropriate as long as it’s offered up as such. Where bloggers go wrong…and PR agencies who don’t “get” social media…is when they aren’t transparent, and are trying to hide their association with or reason for promoting a brand. It’s not the promotion that’s the problem, it’s how the information is served up.

    • http://thirstforwine.co.uk thirstforwine

      thanks Steve. I agree with you on the transparency issue, but sometimes, even that is not enough as you can still annoy readers IF they come wanting something else. However, if I start getting too many I will explore other options. thanks for the input

  • http://richard.mackney.com/ Richard Mackney

    yes

  • http://richard.mackney.com/ Richard Mackney

    Darn it, I really wanted to just say ‘yes’ but feel that I should follow it up.

    As a reader of your blog and tweets I feel that I know your official affiliation (you have mentioned it before) and from knowing that I have the power to decide if the information/deals you publish are in my interest or not. Most of the blogs and tweeple I follow have some sort of agenda anyway.

    I say YES, let me know where I can get the best wine deals even if it is from the places you represent :)

    @mackney

    • http://thirstforwine.co.uk thirstforwine

      knew I could count on you (for more offers and more information) :)